Long Island Fishing Charters & Boat Rentals

Enjoy A Fun Day Onboard Reel Serenity!

Reel Serenity Charters has been in business since 2009 and is a customizable charter service personalized to your boating needs. We offer many options to accommodate all types of chartering on the Great South Bay. You can book a destination cruise to different towns that Fire Island has to offer and go sightseeing, shopping, and dining. Or try a relaxation cruise and stay on the boat to enjoy cocktails and just sunbathe.

Private charters are available where you can hire Captain Carl to drive your own boat so you can entertain business clients or friends and family.

If learning to operate your boat is your goal, we offer hourly boating lessons. Captain Carl will be happy to train you on how to dock and teach you how to use your boat’s electronics, not to mention store GPS tracks for you to follow to your favorite restaurants or marinas.

If you wish to relocate your own yacht to a new marina anywhere on the eastern seaboard, our Yacht transit service is available. You can have peace of mind knowing your boat is in good hands and will be at your destination when you arrive.

What We Do

Our Charter Services

Boat Charter Services

Captain Charter Services

Boat Operation & Lessons

View All Services

Reel Serenity Charters

We proudly offer boat rental and charter services throughout Long Island, New York, including popular destinations such as Fire Island, Fire Island Inlet, Great South Bay, Moriches Inlet, Hempstead Harbor, Moriches Bay, Shinnecock Bay & Inlet, The Rockaways, and offshore fishing in the Atlantic Ocean. Our service area spans Suffolk and Nassau Counties, including Kismet, Ocean Bay Park, Atlantique, and Fair Harbor. We specialize in private Long Island boat charters, sightseeing and diving tours to attractions like the Suffolk County Reefs, as well as Captain for Hire services, boat operator training, and yacht transit.

Text or Call Captain Carl at (516) 359-9094 for Booking OR

Our Work

Photo Gallery

Testimonials

What People Say About Us

5 stars all around.!!!! Capt Carl with Reel Serenity Boat Charter's is the way to go -!!! Worry free boat trips, Capt Carl has expertise knowledge of the Local waters wether it's a fishing trip or a day on the bay or ocean, you're in good hands! He'll put you on fish each and every time..I've been on many of fishing trips with Capt Carl and it's been an Amazing trip each time! Great communication setting up your trip, and from the moment you get on the boat to you get off it's a worry free Great time! The boats are clean, well taken care of and set up right for your trip. A beautiful Fleet of boats to choose from also! I highly recommend Reel Serenity Boat Charters, hands down, Capt Carl is your guy-

Flamingo Gaming
Captain Carl's experience aboard the Robalo was absolute perfection! Our entire group had the BEST time exploring Fire Island. We stopped at a few locations – one, to explore a town, and another to anchor and swim, have lunch, and relax. The ride was smooth, and the boat was pristine. Captain Carl was knowledgeable of the island and very welcoming. He was an excellent communicator, before, during, and after the charter. I highly recommend Captain Carl! Looking forward to the next charter!

Amanda
My 4 friends and I had a wonderful time. We stopped at Fire Island and were able to eat, drink, and party on the boat. The boat is fun as well when it reaches certain speeds. We will definitely be booking Carl again for next summer

Quantia
We had an ABSOLUTE blast with Carl! Not only was he very easy going, he knew all the places to take us. Would 1000% recommend a day out on the water with Carl!

Danielle
Captain Carl was great. We went fishing, and he didn't stop trying to help us catch fish. He took us to numerous locations and taught us the best way to catch a fish. We ended up going near Fire Island to clam and got to pet some adorable dogs. Highly recommend!

Lauren
Wonderful boat that easily cruised into the ocean. Knowledgeable captain with years of experience. A great day of fishing worth skipping work for. Had a great time!

Cristhian
Our day out on the water with Captain Carl was such a blast! Carl planned out such a great day from start to finish, meeting every request and then some. We caught a wonderful ride out to a secluded beach and our kids got the chance to fish for the first time. Couldn’t have asked for anything better – I highly recommend Carl, thank you again for such a fun day!!

Sunitha Dulcie
Carl is a great captain with a great boat! We took a trip to the Sunken Forest and had a video shoot and the trip went smoothly thanks to Carl.

Marcus