Our Exclusive Boat Collection

Are you searching for a safe, well-maintained boat rental in the Greater Long Island area, including Fire Island, Suffolk County, Ocean Beach, Kismet, Ocean Bay Park, Atlantique, Fair Harbor, and Nassau County? Look no further! We offer highly competitive pricing and customizable boat charter services tailored to your fishing, boating, and recreational needs in the beautiful waters of New York. Choose one of our great boat charters below!

24 Foot Robalo (Reel Serenity III)

This Robalo 24 Foot Center Console boat is available to take you, your family and friends on a fast, comfortable and seaworthy boating adventure for 3, 4, 6 or 8 hours. Check out the scenic New York waterways, such as Long Island, Fire Island, Fair Harbor or Ocean Bay Park. There is room for 5 adults. The center console allows sun worshipers plenty of sun, and the bimini top offers coverage from the elements. 

Enjoy cruising to the beautiful local beaches and harbors where you can take a swim and relax. Or, if you prefer, pull-in for lunch or dinner at one of the many restaurants that Fire Island has to offer. Sunset cruises are also an option. As a licensed and experienced captain, you can enjoy a worry-free day on the water.

Booking Options

• 3 Hours = $500
• 4 Hours = $600
• 6 Hours = $800
• 8 Hours = $950

Payment Options

• Payments accepted via Venmo, Zelle
• Pay Now with Venmo ►

Cancellation Policy

1. Free cancellations until 24 hours before the booking start time.
2. Cancellations within 24 hours of the booking time are non-refundable.
3. Due to inclement weather where small craft advisory is issued, Captain Carl reserves the right to cancel the charter and reschedule or refund it.

25 Foot Pilot House (Reel Serenity II)

The Reel Serenity offers fishing charters, cruises around the bay, plus transporting anywhere in Fire Island. Kismet is a convenient 15 minute ride from Bay Shore and a 15-25 minute trip to Atlantique, Ocean Beach and Ocean Bay Park. 

Take advantage of the beautiful beaches and anchor inside the Fire Island inlet, go for a swim or just relax in the sun. We'll customize your charter to your needs for you and your party. If it’s a fishing charter you are looking to do, we supply all the equipment and bait needed. The boat is fully equipped and NYS DEC permitted. It has plenty of rod holders, coolers, navigation equipment, life vests and a safety raft. Reel Serenity was repowered with 2021 twin 175 Suzuki’s which will safely and efficiently take you to the fishing grounds. Reel Serenity is captained and maintained by its owner, Captain Carl.

Booking Options

• 3 Hours = $500
• 4 Hours = $600
• 6 Hours = $800
• 8 Hours = $950

Payment Options

• Payments accepted via Venmo, Zelle
• Pay Now with Venmo ►

Cancellation Policy

1. Free cancellations until 24 hours before the booking start time.
2. Cancellations within 24 hours of the booking time are non-refundable.
3. Due to inclement weather where small craft advisory is issued, Captain Carl reserves the right to cancel the charter and reschedule or refund it.

36 Tiara (Robin Jean)

This boat is a 1988 Classic 36 FT Tiara Convertible

Welcome to the Robin Jean, she is a well maintained and updated beauty. She has two staterooms and one bathroom with an outdoor shower on the swim platform. It’s the perfect boat for a party of up to 6 people to cruise the bay or anchor up for a day in the sun and just relax or party. The boat is directly across from Kismet (20-minute drive) and 45-minute drive to Ocean Beach and Ocean Bay Park. Call for more details. We look forward to hearing from you.

Booking Options

• 2 Hours = $900*
• 4 Hours = $1200*
• 6 Hours = $1600*
• 8 Hours = $1800*

*Pricing does not include fuel.

Payment Options

• Payments accepted via Venmo, Zelle
• Pay Now with Venmo ►

Cancellation Policy

1. Free cancellations until 24 hours before the booking start time.
2. Cancellations within 24 hours of the booking time are non-refundable.
3. Due to inclement weather where small craft advisory is issued, Captain Carl reserves the right to cancel the charter and reschedule or refund it.

Choose Reel Serenity Charters for your New York boat charter services, and explore the beautiful, peaceful waterways and attractions of the greater Long Island and Suffolk County areas.

1. Fire Island: Known for its stunning natural beauty, tranquil waters, and beaches, Fire Island offers a peaceful and scenic escape, perfect for boating, fishing, and exploring the coastline.

2. Suffolk County: This area boasts some of the best fishing spots, as well as calm bays and inlets. You will enjoy both inshore and offshore fishing or a leisurely cruise along the Long Island Sound.

3. Ocean Beach: This charming village on Fire Island is a great spot for boat charters, offering easy access to both the Atlantic Ocean and the Great South Bay. Ideal for swimming, fishing, and sightseeing.

4. Kismet and Atlantique: These quieter areas on Fire Island are great for a relaxing day on the water, whether you’re fishing, sunbathing, or exploring the island’s natural beauty.

5. Ocean Bay Park and Fair Harbor: These waterfront communities are perfect for those seeking a mix of relaxation and adventure, with beautiful views and calm waters that are ideal for boating and watersports.

6. Nassau County: Heading towards Nassau County allows you to explore the iconic waters around the Hempstead Bay, with the possibility of fishing, cruising, or even venturing out towards the more dynamic areas closer to the New York Harbor.

Each location offers a unique experience, whether you prefer serene waters, abundant fishing opportunities, or exploring scenic shorelines. Whether it’s fishing, sightseeing, or simply relaxing on the water, we have the perfect boat charter for you!